Defensive indifference - is it unwise? I'm a longtime baseball nut with the privilege of having a 15-year-old son who is steadily approaching matching my passion for the game. We don't agree on everything but do share a deep respect for the game and its traditions; however, every so often he has an opinion that seriously challenges my long-held notions and gives me pause. In baseball statistics, stolen bases are denoted by SB. If the defense makes no attempt to put the baserunner out (for example, if the catcher doesn't even look his way), the play is scored as defensive indifference (also called fielder's indifference), and no stolen base is credited to the runner. Defensive indifference is generally only ...
Video shows what defensive indifference means. An official scoring judgement in which a runner is not credited with a stolen base because the team playing the field did not try to stop the steal. Defensive Indifference: Bumpus Quest (Part… Defensive Indifference: Bumpus Quest (Part 1) This content is for Premium, Super-Premium and Premium Monthly members only.
In baseball, a stolen base occurs when a runner advances to a base to which he is not entitled and the official scorer rules that the advance should be credited to the action of the runner. The umpires determine whether the runner is safe or out at the next base, but the official scorer rules on the question of credit or blame for the advance under Rule 10. At this point, an announcer chimes in with the helpful reminder: "For those of you scoring at home, that was not a stolen base because the defensive indifference rule was in effect." Huh? Let me get this straight: Joey B. had no right to that base. He had only earned his way onto first. In order to reach second base, he would have to be ... difference between stolen base and defensive indifference We will try and answer Questions in this forum. If you are having any issues with iScore Baseball, this is probably the best place to start.
Defensive indifference: The official scorer shall not score a stolen base when a runner advances solely because of the defensive team's indifference to the runner's advance. General Baseball; Baseball 101, Coaching & Fundamentals; If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. We've learned that interference is an infraction that is committed by the offense (base runners and batters, primarily). However, there is one special case where it's the defense that commits the interference – defensive interference, commonly known as "catcher's interference."All other infractions by the defense that impede offensive players fall under the rules for obstruction.
In baseball, “defensive indifference” is when the defense allows a baserunner to advance to the next base without an effort to get him out. This happens frequently near the end of a game when there are two outs in an inning and a lead of at least two runs to protect. Wins Above Replacement or Wins Above Replacement Player, commonly abbreviated to WAR or WARP, is a non-standardized sabermetric baseball statistic developed to sum up "a player's total contributions to his team". A player's WAR value is claimed to be the number of additional wins his team has achieved above the number of expected team wins if that player were substituted with a replacement ...
A defensive indifference ruling is really there to keep players from raising their stolen base stats unjustly. Even if a hitter hits a home run when a pitcher lobs a BP fastball right over the plate, the batter gets credit for the homer. As a base runner, the circumstances are different and thus a separate ruling was put in place. What counts as a stolen base? How do we define what base a runner is "entitled to"? And why is defensive indifference different from a stolen base? I mean, the guy stole a base didn't he, I ... Defensive indifference is dumb, and teams should feel bad for practicing it New, 52 comments Plus Bartolo Colon has a new tattoo, and umpires won’t stop getting in the way.
editor's note: this is a repost of an item originally appearing in my Baseball Scoring Rules site. Towards the end of my scoring rule article covering stolen bases, I make a mention of the situation that is scored as defensive indifference.And if you read it, you can tell that I'm not extremely fond of this rule the way that it is written. Nick Faleris, Adam McInturff and John Eshleman wrap the 2018 AFL coverage and discuss 2080 Baseball's All-AFL Team selections. The post Defensive Indifference (Limited Series) — AFL Episode 6 appeared first on 2080 Baseball.
Defensive Indifference is a play in the later stages of a game in which the defensive team, either ahead or behind by a large amount allows a player to advance a base without any attempt to put the runner out. Origin. The modern steal rule was put into place in 1898. Before then, any time a runner took an extra base (such as advancing to third base from first on a single) he was awarded a stolen base. Defensive Indifference: Ep. 3 — Org Reviews (Rays) In Episode 3 of Defensive Indifference: A 2080 Baseball Podcast , Dave DeFreitas and Nick J. Faleris discuss a Rays system on the rise, and tackle a question from the Defensive Indifference Mailbag on potential Dodgers trade packages for Twins second baseman Brian Dozier .
Defensive indifference is a sleepy but established rule that has been in Major League Baseball for 89 years. Bob Waterman, a senior baseball staffer at Elias, said the addendum, “No stolen base ... Defensive Indifference: A 2080 Baseball Podcast by Dave DeFreitas and Nick J. Faleris. 2080 Baseball's Dave DeFreitas and Nick Faleris discuss baseball's stars of tomorrow through the lens of scouting and player development.
Defensive indifference is a really subjective call. If the scorer determines that there was a strategic attempt to stop that baserunner from stealing, it's still a stolen base. You didn't provide enough information to make a decision. Was the runner being held on? Was there a player covering second? What inning was it and what was the score? These are people whose physical skills often seem something beyond human. When you watch a baseball player, you might feel concerned about the strain on their arm, or about the muscles in their legs—baseball injuries. Rarely does one feel any awareness of the fist-sized muscle that drives all of that activity, even as you might feel yours ...
Defensive indifference: The official scorer shall not score a stolen base when a runner advances solely because of the defensive team's indifference to the runner's advance. The official scorer ... defensive-indifference definition: Noun 1. (baseball) An official scoring judgement in which a runner is not credited with a stolen base because the team playing the field did not try to stop the steal. This typically occurs late in a game when the fielding team is ... In Episode 12 of Defensive Indifference: A 2080 Baseball Podcast, Dave DeFreitas and Nick J. Faleris tackle a wealth of talent in the Houston Astros organization.Already poised to compete for an AL West title and deep run into October, the ‘Stros have reinforcements to call on in the short term, as well as multiple waves of talent rolling towards the big club at the lower levels.
If a catcher decides not to attempt to throw out a runner, then it is called Defensive Indifference…and the runner is not awarded a stolen base! This makes no sense! That would be like if a shortstop goes deep in the hole and decides not to throw it to first, then the batter would not […] The following year lead to big changes in my baseball fandom. First of all, in 1989 or 1990 a relative got me a subscription to Baseball Digest. Before that point I was mainly limited to baseball cards, newspaper blurbs and box scores, and an occasional national TV game to keep up with that was going on within baseball. Baseball Digest allowed ...
But even though Baseball-Reference nor anybody else keeps Defensive Indifference stats (which, by the way, is officially scored “DI/FC” [Fielder’s Choice]), I can tell you for a fact that in the last week alone two base runners that the Dodgers allowed to take second base on Defensive Indifference came around to score – including last night’s game against the lowly Diamondbacks ... Defensive indifference is a sleepy but established rule that has been in Major League Baseball for 89 years. Bob Waterman, a senior baseball staffer at Elias, said the addendum, “No stolen base shall be credited to a runner who is allowed to advance without an effort being made to stop him,” was placed in the 1920 rule book. The rule is ...
Defensive indifference is a sleepy but established rule that has been in Major League Baseball for 89 years. Bob Waterman, a senior baseball staffer at Elias, said the addendum, “No stolen base shall be credited to a runner who is allowed to advance without an effort being made to stop him,” was placed in the 1920 rule book. When it's the bottom of the ninth and they let the runner go to 2nd base. I don't understand it, is it to prevent a bad throw to second? I'm an ignoramous I know. Defensive Indifference: Bumpus Quest (Part… Defensive Indifference: Bumpus Quest (Part 2) This content is for Premium, Super-Premium and Premium Monthly members only.
Most scorekeepers in youth baseball incorrectly score stolen bases, wild pitches, passed balls, and defensive indifference. It's really not that complicated. Here's a complete breakdown of how to score these things correctly... 2080 Baseball's Dave DeFreitas and Nick Faleris discuss baseball's stars of tomorrow through the lens of scouting and player development.
This is a baseball statistic which depends on the official’s scorer sole discretion at each ballpark. Defensive indifference scoring is normally seen when a game is out of hand in the ninth inning. Either ahead or behind by a large amount, the defensive team allows a player to advance a base without attempting to put the runner out. You've all seen the situation 1,000 times. Runners on first and third with less than two outs. Runner at 1st takes of for second after the first pitch and is safe, as there is no throw down. I see lots of books scoring this as defensive indifference, but I still award an SB unless the game is... I didn’t notice when Clayton Kershaw jogged onto the field on Sunday afternoon in Seattle. I knew it was going to be my last MLB game of the season, so I’d spent some extra money on a 100-level seat—out in right-center field, about six rows up from the wall, mostly sheltered from what sun was getting through the layer of red-grey smoke that hung over the ballpark.
defensive indifference Main article: Defensive indifference When the defense allows a baserunner to advance one or more bases. The runner then does not get credit for a stolen base because the base was "given" not "stolen".  ~ - when the defense allows the base runner to steal a base without a play on them Many baseball terms have to do ... Meanwhile "defensive indifference" conjures up a defensive squad that could not care less, which is hilarious. Baseball is often like that in its phraseology; another example is the "daisy cutter," a ground ball that is hit so hard and close to the ground that it could chop off any daisies sprouting through the glass. Sure, "hard hit ground ... Defensive indifference is usually only scored instead of a stolen base when the game is in a late inning and the team with the stealing baserunner is down by more than one run. MLB Rule 10.07(g) defines defensive indifference. Strategy
If somebody is on first and they try to steal second base, but the defensive team doesn't even try to throw him out. Defensive indifferenced usually occur when one team is blowing the other team out and the defensive team doesn't really care if the base runner is on second instead of first While the vast majority of interference infractions are committed by the offense team (batter, runner), there is a common way for a defensive player to be charged with interference. It is commonly called catcher’s interference. Catcher’s Interference The defensive interference rule specifies that a fielder may not hinder or prevent a batter from hitting a …
Defensive Indifference - DI Tweet This baseball statistic, which depends on the decision of the official scorer, refers to when a runner advances a base on a pitch but is not given credit for a stolen base because the opposing team made no attempt to hold him at the previous base, and no attempt was made at the base he advanced to. (baseball) An official scoring judgement in which a runner is not credited with a stolen base because the team playing the field did not try to stop the steal. This typically occurs late in a game when the fielding team is winning by at least two runs. The play was scored as defensive indifference In Episode 5 of this special limited AFL Series of Defensive Indifference: A 2080 Baseball Podcast, hosts Ryan Sullivan and John Eshleman are joined by Nick Faleris as the three discuss this year's Fall Stars Game, featuring the top talents in the Fall League.
Defensive indifference is a sleepy but established rule that has been in Major League Baseball for 89 years. Bob Waterman, a senior baseball staffer at Elias, said the addendum, “No stolen base shall be credited to a runner who is allowed to advance without an effort being made to stop him,” was placed in the 1920 rule book. It sounds easy. You know what a stolen base is. But the truth is that most fans, coaches, and scorekeepers don’t know how to score stolen bases when other factors are added to the mix.Some of those factors:Wild pitchesPassed ballsDefensive indifferenceThe result is that scorekeepers will often over or under-report stolen bases.I’m trying to do a public service here. Most scorekeepers do ...Read More